Kelly, try a double ended kayak paddle and see if you like it. Most paddlers can travel faster, turn easier, and tire less. You get a lot more paddle into the water, and don't have to do steering corrections via J stroke and all that folderoll. Learn a simple bow rudder and stern rudder strokes and you will see how much faster you can turn, and how much better when you're turning against a stiff breeze.
To maximize your use of it, don't paddle by windmilling your arms like most folks mistakenly do. Hold the paddle out in front of you in a comfortable position, dip one end in the water, and turn from the waist in that direction. When the paddle is as far back as your hip, roll the other end into the water and turn in that direction from the waist. Keep the paddle shaft parallel with your shoulders; turn from the waist and use your back muscles for more power and less fatigue.
When starting to learn this, do it slowly so you get the pattern. It's more important to learn how to do it right than to generate speed at first. In 10 to 15 minutes you will already be going faster this way than you ever would with a single blade paddle.
After trying one, if you don't like it, just go back to a single blade paddle and enjoy.