Anybody who has ever had the mis-fortune to use an overhead casting reel from the beach and casting into the wind can attest to what a bitch they are in these conditions. (even the very good reels) never mind the hours spent in stripping the bloody things down and cleaning them after a trip.
with an Alvey, you simply bring it home, hose it off (if you feel like it) and put it away.
I just don't understand why they are not more popular, particularly with beach fishermen.
There is an argument by some that they are not sporting - to just have a direct wind reel and to just wind the fish in. This is BS IMHO. What is unsporting about playing out a solid fish on light line without the aid of high teck drag, relying completely on the skill and reflexes of the angler?