A round bottomed boat is like a ( heavy ) person with a beer belly , sometimes it is harder for him to get threw a tight place then a ( skinny ) flat bellied person. The round bottom sticks out and takes more water to float it then a nice flat bottom one .... So the flat bottom will get into tighter areas then a round or "V" Bottom one will. The flat bottom has a lot less draft ( water needed to float it ) then the others. Taking the same size of the boat and the weight in it into consideration.
Besides the round bottom or "V" one will be tippy as heck when it gets hung up on a log. Or if it hits an object like a stump it can take a 90 degree turn which means the operator of the boat goes overboard and swimming with the motor running and with luck does not fall victim to the spinning prop. At the worse the flat bottom will tip to one side and give you a moment to panic with one side high in the air or just sit there as solid as if it was on a sandbar if you managed to hit it straight on. Or just slide over it , usually sliding over it creating some problems for the lower foot of your motor as it passes under your boat.
Best bet is don't hit any stumps and slid over the logs. Or better yet , go slow when in new waters.
I learned that a long time ago down here at a young age. Later it was reinforced when on a lot of the trips the guys in round bottom canoes got hung up where my flat bottomed pirogue just slid threw without any problems. They were back there cussing , pushing , pulling and doing all sorts of things to get un-hung. Even getting out and balancing on the log while pulling the boat over it , hand over hand style. :evil:
It depends on the water you want to travel , open water then the round or "V" Bottom , back or shallow waters then the flat bottom. Jon Boats are designed as back ( skinny ) water boats that can be operate in open water, the best of both worlds.
As Jack said..........
The main thing is to have the bottom well made to take any abuse if it would come along and it normally does at some time.
Chuck.
Besides the round bottom or "V" one will be tippy as heck when it gets hung up on a log. Or if it hits an object like a stump it can take a 90 degree turn which means the operator of the boat goes overboard and swimming with the motor running and with luck does not fall victim to the spinning prop. At the worse the flat bottom will tip to one side and give you a moment to panic with one side high in the air or just sit there as solid as if it was on a sandbar if you managed to hit it straight on. Or just slide over it , usually sliding over it creating some problems for the lower foot of your motor as it passes under your boat.
Best bet is don't hit any stumps and slid over the logs. Or better yet , go slow when in new waters.
I learned that a long time ago down here at a young age. Later it was reinforced when on a lot of the trips the guys in round bottom canoes got hung up where my flat bottomed pirogue just slid threw without any problems. They were back there cussing , pushing , pulling and doing all sorts of things to get un-hung. Even getting out and balancing on the log while pulling the boat over it , hand over hand style. :evil:
It depends on the water you want to travel , open water then the round or "V" Bottom , back or shallow waters then the flat bottom. Jon Boats are designed as back ( skinny ) water boats that can be operate in open water, the best of both worlds.
As Jack said..........
The main thing is to have the bottom well made to take any abuse if it would come along and it normally does at some time.
Chuck.